Cast Replacement List (In alphabetical order)
*Name in bold indicates original performer in role.
+Indicates cast member on closing performance.
| The Narrator (El Gallo) | ||
| Jerry Orbach* George Lee Andrews Joe Bellomo Matthew Bennett Donald Billett Paul Blankenship John Boni Lance Brodie Roger Alan Brown David Brummel Jim Charles Keith Charles Douglas Clark Bert Convy Jack Crowder David Cryer John Cunningham David Edwards+ Joseph Galiano Robert Goss Nils Hedrick Chris Invar |
Kenneth Kantor Michael Licata Steve McDonough Jack Metter Kim Moore Richard Muenz Roger Neil George Ogee Sal Provenza David Rexroad Chapman Roberts Hal Robinson Gene Rupert John Savarese Robert Vincent Smith David Snell Don Stewart Michael Tartel Tom Urich Martin Vidnovic |
|
| The Girl (Luisa) | ||
| Rita Gardner* Leta Anderson Jennifer Lee Andrews Judy Blazer Elizabeth Bruzzese Alice Cannon Kristin Chenoweth Elizabeth Cherry Glory Crampton Karen Culliver Carole Demas Ann Fisher Eileen Fulton Virginia Gregory Lorrie Harrison Natasha Harper+ Erin Hill Cheryl Home Carla Huston Leilani Johnson Betsy Joslyn Anne Kaye |
Beverly Lambert Royce Lenella Christine Long Debbie McLeod Carolyn Mignini Kathy Morath Marty Morris Allison Munn Amy Niles Caryn Ann Osofsky Sarah Rice Gina Schuh-Turner Heather Spore Liza Stuart Kate Suber Kathy Vestuto B.J. Ward Sharon Werner Katie White Marilyn Whitehead Joan Wiest |
|
| The Boy (Matt) | ||
| Kenneth Nelson* Matthew Bennett Paul Blankenship Jack Blockton Ralph Bruneau Gino Conforti Craig Corneilla Bruce Cryer Jimmy Dodge Evan Farmer David Gebel Richard Gervais Paul Giovanni Jeremy Ellison-Gladstone+ Michael Glenn-Smith Charles Hagerty Erik Howell Phil Killian |
Jeff Knight Gary Krawford Howard Lawrence Richard Lincoln Ty McConnell Steve McDonough Eric Meyersfield Kim Moore Bill Perlach Sam Ratclifte Peter Reckell Richard Roland Richard Rothbard Christopher Seppe Steve Skiles Bob Spencer Geoffrey Taylor |
|
| The Boy’s Father (Hucklebee) | ||
| William Larsen* F. Murray Abraham Donald Babcock Charles Blackburn Ira Joe Fisher Richard P. Gang Edward Garrabrandt Charles Goff Philip Baker Hall Jay Hampton Gordon G. Jones David Keiserman Richard A. Kennerson Kenneth Kimmins |
Richard Kinter Tom Lacy Dick Latassa Lore Noto Dale O’Brien Ed Penn George Riddle David Sabin Ray Stewart Hansford Rowe Bill Weeden+ Charles Welch |
|
| The Girl’s Father (Bellomy) | ||
| Hugh Thomas* Arthur Anderson Charles Blackburn Maurice Edwards Charles Goff Byron Grant John High Conzalo Madurga John J. Martin John Martin Michael Mulheren |
Ken Parker Henry Quinn Jerry Russak Jack Schmidt Ray Stewart William Tost+ Sy Travers David Vaughan David Vogal |
|
| The Actor (Henry) | ||
| Thomas Bruce* (stage name for author Tom Jones) |
||
| F. Murray Abraham Hugh Alexander Donald Babcock Matthew Bennett Ed Gall Franco Geraci Justin Gray Stanley Jay Jay Hampton John Hefferman J. C. Hoyt+ |
Bryan Hull Elliot Levine Russell Lieb Lowry Miller Robert Molnar Gary Nairns Seamus O’Brien Ron Prather George Riddle Geronimo Sands Curt Williams |
|
| The Man Who Dies (Mortimer) | ||
| George Curley* Samuel Assaid Donald Babcock Matthew Bennett Joel Bernstein Peter Blaxill John Bundrick+ James Cook Ed Garrabrandt Richard Kuss Jay Hampton Bryan Hull |
Richard A. Kennerson Tom Lacy Earl Levine William McIntyre Michael Nostrand Liam O’Begley Robert Oliver Don Pomes Bill Preston Curt Williams Robert Worms |
|
| The Mute (Mute) | ||
| Richard Stauffer* Richard Barrie Matthew Bennett Paul Blankenship Robert Brigham Douglas Clark Jim Charles James Cook Robert Crest Glenn Davish Dan Delafield Jake Dengel Jay Douglas Kathy Faul |
Tom Flagg David Gebel Frano Geraci Richard Gervais Alan Hemingway Steve McDonough Kim Moore+ Ron Prather Peter Reckell Robert Schrock Les Shenkel Richard Thayer John Thomas Waite |
|
| The Handyman | ||
| Jay Hampton* George Drake Richard Drake and anyone who took a notion to play it. The role was written out of the show. |
||
| The Pianist | ||
| Julian Stein* Nancy Ford Wally Harper Jack Lee William F. McDaniel Dorothy Martin Gregory Martindale Jeremie Michael+ |
Jimmy Roberts Penna Rose Jeff Saver Kim Douglas Steiner Norman Weiss Ethyl Will |
|
| The Harpist | ||
| Beverly Mann* Nancy Allen Pattee Cohen Saul Davis Elizabeth Etters Henry Fannelli Sally Foster Nanette Norton Winifred Wynné Starks Andre Tarantiles Hank Whitmire+ |
||